My Files Keep Messing Up

Yeah, so I apparently do everything wrong when it comes to trying to create the cut-out thing that I'm just gonna go ahead and label as a phenomenon because I cannot figure out how to do it without my whole project file rage quiting on me. ...so I used the guy's file. And it still wasn't of any help. Whoopie.

 

On Monday, I had the reflection all nice and stuff and then I open up the file today and BAM.

 

Nothing good.